Math & Thinking · Free short lesson

Test a claim with a counterexample

Use one valid example to check whether an always-claim is true.

Choose a grade, then try the method.

Try an original question, explore a worked example, and apply the method to a fresh question. Select a supported practice grade above; no account or card is needed.

In the Math & Thinking program

  • Number relationships, expressions and grade-appropriate mathematics
  • Logic, constraints, claims and counterexamples
  • Creative options, evidence and explaining a decision
  • Guided review and a structured learning path
Explore coverage across grades →

Method preview · Example at Grade 3

What you’ll learn.

One number can show that an 'every' claim is false.

  1. Read exactly which numbers the claim covers.
  2. Find a number in that group.
  3. Check whether it breaks the claimed rule.

12 is even and ends in 2, so it breaks the rule. 20 supports the rule, and 15 is not even.

A counterexample must fit the starting description and break the claimed rule.

Choose a practice grade above to open the questions and teaching help for that grade.